Shoulder surgery is one of the most common operations in the U.S. More than 210,000 Americans have it every year.
The procedure is supposed to cure or improve “impingement.” This is what doctors call the pain and restricted range of movement in the shoulder.1
The surgeon threads an arthroscope through a small incision to repair or remove damaged tissue. This decompresses shoulder tissue to supposedly allow easier and pain-free movement.
It seems very straightforward. And you’d think there would be little doubt it’s effective, since doctors perform it so often.
But there has been surprisingly little research on shoulder decompression surgery. A major new study was the first to directly compare it to a placebo.
Researchers at the University of Helsinki in Finland followed 189 patients suffering from shoulder pain for at least three months.
The patients received one of three treatments:
- Decompression surgery
- Placebo surgery (arthroscopy was used only to examine the shoulder joint)
- Exercise therapy
Two years later, the patients were asked to assess their shoulder pain.
Researchers: Shoulder Surgery Is ‘Useless’
Shoulder pain was substantially reduced in all three groups. However, decompression surgery provided no greater relief than placebo surgery.2
And the exercise group also got about the same pain reduction and functionality as the other groups. The researchers found there were no “clinically significant” differences among the three groups.
Dr. Teppo Järvinen is a clinical professor of Orthopedics and Traumatology at the University of Helsinki. He was the study’s principal investigator.
“These results show that surgery is not an effective form of treatment for this most common shoulder complaint,” he said. “With results as crystal clear as this, we expect that this will lead to major changes in contemporary treatment practices.”
Doctors need to stop doing surgery for routine shoulder pain, Dr. Järvinen said.
“It seems clear that instead of surgery, the treatment of such patients should hinge on non-operative means,” he added. “We would avoid performing hundreds of thousands useless surgeries every year in the world.”
The study recently was published in The BMJ.
Two Best Exercises for Shoulder Pain
Shoulder impingement usually occurs later in life. About 10% of Americans complain of shoulder pain. But in seniors the figure more than doubles to 21%.3
It can be the result of years of poor posture…standing or sitting with stooped shoulders. Over the years, your shoulder tissue becomes compressed. This leads to impingement and pain.4
Dr. John M. Kirsch is author of the book Shoulder Pain? The Solution and Prevention. He says that 99% of shoulder pain can be cured with one simple exercise. It’s called the dead hang.5
The Dead Hang
The only equipment you need is a pull-up bar or another type of horizontal bar that you can hang from.
Grip the bar with an overhand grip. Have your hands at the same width as your shoulders. Allow your shoulders to relax. Don’t squeeze your shoulder blades together.
Simply hang. Don’t try to do a pull-up.
Start slowly. It may be painful at first. If you can’t do a complete hang with your feet off the floor, do a partial hang. Keep your feet on a stool or the floor while gradually putting pressure on your shoulders.
If you don’t have a bar high enough to stay off the ground, you can use a lower bar and bend your knees. Allow as much of your weight as possible to hang from the bar.
Work your way up to three sets of 30-second hangs per day.
The Farmer’s Carry
If you don’t have access to an overhead bar, you can get similar benefits with an exercise called the farmer’s carry.
Grab a dumbbell or kettlebell in each hand. Your arms and hands should hang straight down at the outside of your thigh.
Stand erect. Relax and round your shoulders so they are stretched downwards by the weights. Either stand in place or walk forward.
Start with a weight and time limit that you can handle. The goal is to ultimately use two dumbbells that total half your weight. For example, if you weigh 200 pounds, your goal would be to carry two 50-pound dumbbells.
Over time, build up to three sets of 30 seconds if you are stationary. If you are walking, walk 30 yards for each set.
Editor’s Note: There are other powerful, natural solutions that can help you conquer joint pain…Like the desert herb that may replace pain prescriptions for both osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis.